Tuesday, 1 March 2011

Dementia Map

This comes into the category of 'this-is-very-interesting-info-but-what-is-it-telling-me? kind of thing.The Alzheimer's Society with the help of Tesco(?) have compiled a study showing rates of dementia compared with rates of diagnosis and comes to the conclusion that dementia is under-diagnosed. Scotland does well; Belfast does better and Wales has done badly in this respect. England varies. I'm not sure what to make of it all.

When my mum was diagnosed with dementia, we didn't tell her that she had it. There was absolutely no benefit to be had by doing this, apart from upsetting her. The diagnosis opened the door to things like Aricept, Attendance Allowance, disabled aids and a place at a local day centre that specialised in patients with early dementia. There is definitely a value in having a diagnosis; there is also an expense in it for the local authority which is maybe what these figures indicate. But there are a lot of people who don't go to the doctor when they suspect dementia, because they know there's no cure and they are afraid to have their fears confirmed. It's also an issue of independence. Not everyone has relatives who are friendly towards them and a diagnosis of dementia can mean an early curtailing of freedoms. Not to mention that a third of people with dementia live alone and never get down to the doctor in the first place.

I think this map is telling us that dementia is under-diagnosed, but not why, and that is something that we really need to know.

2 comments:

hyperCRYPTICal said...

Hi Julie.

Like yourself, I find the map confusing. I would be interested to know how they reach their figures. It is stated that 4 out of 10 cases of dementia are undiagnosed. How do they know? If they are undiagnosed - how do they reach this conclusion? How do they know these unfortunate people exist? Where did they find these undiagnosed individuals?

Like your good self, I have been 'touched' by dementia. My mother too; she also did not know of her diagnosis - it was her dread after working in a psychogeriatic ward. It would not have been 'therapeutic' for her to know.

My husband (early onset) too is unaware of his diagnosis - as he did not want to know the outcome of investigations after watching my mothers decline. Having said that - he does now and again have insight and I sensitively present reasons (TIA's)for his memory problems and do not state that he hasn't dementia nor thrust in his face that he does.

It is important that dementia is brought out into the open and is understood by society in general
- but to me, the map is meaningless and I wonder what it is all about.

Anna :o]

Julie said...

I wish with these studies that they would tell you how they were done. I mean, did they stop people in Tesco and ask them or something? What was Tesco's involvement in this? And what were the numbers involved? All v confusing.